Same ol' slop

email-addthis printer-addthis favorites-addthis facebook-addthis digg-addthis | Share

19 Jan 2012 08:23:57
Category: D&D

We ain't had nothing to eat but maggity bread for three stinking days!

The 5th Edition of Dungeons and Dragons is on it's way. Hooray?

Do we really need yet another edition? When I started looking into playing D&D again I found more than enough of what I was looking for in the retro clones and in the community called the "OSR". I found hobbyists in the mold of Gygax and Arneson who were interested in playing the games as much as making them. OSR writers understand the game because they have spent thousands of hours playing them. You can't pay writers to have that passion, you can't hire marketers to research that, you can't hire beta testers to give you that kind of feedback, and you certainly can't do that while aggressively planning the next 3 to 5 years of product line so Hasbro's top execs will buy into it. They can slap the "brand" on what ever they want, but the game will always be this:
Rules Cyclopedia
or this:
PHB
or even like this:
od&d

Try It Free For 60 Days No Obligation

Don't get too excited about the open play test of the 5th edition. Why? Because the parameters are prearranged and they don't plan on making sweeping changes based on the play tests. An open play test is about showing you they "care" so you'll buy their knock off of a classic.

"See Now You Can Trust Me, I'm A Nice Guy"

Not taking the bait on their limited edition release material, they're just prepping you psychologically to buy product. It's classic sales technique to get the shopper to say "yes".

Moderated Comments

Pretty much

Posted: 19 Jan 2012 22:17:54

badger2305 says:

I think you've pretty much nailed it. I don't see much reason to jump onto the bandwagon.

Playtesting

Posted: 26 Jan 2012 11:22:33

says:

What makes you think they wont listen to the feedback from playtesters?

Parameters

Posted: 26 Jan 2012 19:52:15

says:

It's not that they won't "listen" it's that the parameters have been set. Sure they'll "tweak" but no change to major elements. It's a corporation, they've already invested in this thing. They're look for tweaks not remakes. If they had wanted feedback for sweeping changes they would have involved the gaming community much earlier in the design process. All that aside, I think the OSR has out grown the need for an official mouthpiece. I know I'm not interested.

All comments are reviewed before they are posted.